
And To Rick Scott, That's The Problem
(UPDATED BELOW)
While inaccuracies in the voter lists continue to mount, and Rick Scott pushes ahead to purge U.S. citizens who are very much eligible to vote in Florida from the rolls anyway, he lost another voter suppression battle in court.
U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle struck down a provision of the controversial Florida voter suppression law pushed and passed by Republicans and signed by Gov. Scott that prompted the the lawsuit by the League of Women Voters, who were forced to stop registering voters because of harsh time restrictions. Violations of those restrictions would have imposed harsh penalties and fines.
The law imposed a 48-hour deadline for turning in forms by third party groups, the provision the judge barred from enforcement today.
From the ruling:
The statute and rule impose a harsh and impractical 48-hour deadline for an organization to deliver applications to a voter registration office and effectively prohibit an organization from mailing applications in. And the statute and rule impose burdensome record-keeping and reporting requirements that serve little if any purpose, thus rendering them unconstitutional” even if they do not violate the NVRA; (National Voting Rights Act) a primary injuntion barring enforcement of those provisions is denied.
Hinkle's ruling did not include other parts of the law still in question such as a reduced number of early voting days, the cancellation of voting on the Sunday prior to election day, and restrictions making it harder to vote for those who have moved, or made address changes, which would make voting harder for certain targeted groups like college students.
Sen. Bill Nelson, who opposed the law and asked Gov. Scott not to sign it said Thursday
“This law clearly was designed to stop people from voting, and I’m glad to see the judge’s ruling.”
Earlier this year, Nelson also asked the U.S. Justice Department for an investigation into whether the law was deliberately intended to curb voting among young voters, seniors and minorities. He also brought the U.S. Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights and Human Rights to Tampa to hold an investigative hearing on the law in January.
At the time, Democratic Sen. Dick Durbin wrote a letter to Gov. Rick Scott requesting that he appear at that hearing, but Scott blatantly ignored the letter and refused to attend the hearing. In a flippant response, Scott's spokesman said:
"Governor Scott won’t be responding to the senator’s letter. He’s focused on passing meaningful jobs legislation, education and PIP reform and respectfully declines to further explain a law he didn’t write."
Florida Democratic Party Chair Rod Smith gave this response to Thursday's ruling:
"As we have stated from the beginning, the GOP's voter suppression law is nothing more than a thinly veiled attempt to keep Floridians from making their voices heard at the polls. Under Gov. Rick Scott, Florida Republican's have led an unprecedented assault on voting rights – a basic right of all Americans – and it must stop. Today's decision is a victory for the people of Florida and a defeat to the extremist GOP leadership in Tallahassee. "
Meanwhile, Rick Scott's blatant attempt to purge voters continues in spite of the fact that errors are being made and those who have every right to vote are being forced to prove their rights or lose them in the face of an approaching deadline. Today Florida GOP chair Lenny Curry admitted there are problems with the data, but that they will continue with the purge regardless.
In some counties the Supervisors of Elections have halted the purge. So far those are Hillsborough, Leon and Palm Beach Counties. Progress Florida has compiled a list of all the county election offices along with the name and phone numbers of their Supervisors so voters can call and urge them to join those above and stop the purge.
It shouldn't have to come down to the voters having to ask that a purge wrought with errors be stopped any more than the burden of proof should fall on an eligible U.S. citizen to continue to exercise their right to vote. But sadly, in Rick Scott's Florida, it does.
Just take it from Rep. Dennis Baxley (R-Stand Your Ground) who said this about the state's non-existent voter fraud problem, the voter purge, and the potential for prosecution:
"We need to protect the integrity of the system and ensure that people who aren't eligible to vote aren't casting ballots. The elections supervisors are going to send any names they find suspicious to the state attorneys, but the prosecutors have bigger fish to fry than this."
Rick Scott has bigger fish to fry too. A repeat of the 2000 election, which he'd like to hand to Mitt Romney.
He can't have legal voters get in his way.
UPDATE:
Shortly after this post was published, the Justice Department sent a letter to Florida Secretary of State Ken Detzner ordering the state to stop Rick Scott's voter purge because the process hasn't been cleared under the Voting Rights Act. Details here.